Foot traffic is declining across major chains, and the trend isn’t isolated. Target recently marked its tenth straight week of declining visits, with a 7.9% drop for the week of March 31, according to Placer.ai. But they’re not alone. Retail giants like Walmart and Best Buy are reporting similar slowdowns.
At first glance, inflation and evolving consumer budgets appear to be the usual suspects. But there’s more to the story. Today’s consumers are navigating purchases with sharper scrutiny about price, yes, but also about brand alignment with values and cultural relevance. Retailers are finding themselves at the intersection of commerce and culture, and missteps can be costly.
One flashpoint has been the retraction or softening of DEI (Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion) programs. In some cases, these shifts have sparked consumer backlash, eroding trust and impacting foot traffic. Retailers that once wore social initiatives as badges of progress now face public scrutiny over perceived backpedaling.
This isn’t just about politics it’s about perception, purpose, and the evolving role of retail in public life. As consumers demand more than products seeking transparency, representation, and accountability retailers must recalibrate. The industry’s reckoning isn’t just with declining visits, but with its place in a rapidly changing cultural and economic landscape.
@Target‘s recent decision to scale back its Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) initiatives has sparked significant controversy and consumer backlash. Once celebrated for its commitment to DEI, including a pledge to invest $2 billion in Black-owned businesses by 2025, Target’s reversal has led to a notable decline in customer foot traffic and sales. In the four weeks ending February 9, 2025, Target experienced nearly 5 million fewer shopping trips, while competitors like Costco, which maintained their DEI commitments, saw substantial gains in customer visits
Walking the Line: DEI, Brand Identity & Consumer Trust
Target’s foot traffic slump is more than a short term performance dip; it may reflect a larger disconnect between the brand and parts of its consumer base. Once celebrated for its progressive stances and inclusive product lines, the company recently made headlines for scaling back certain DEI commitments. This pivot has sparked criticism from multiple fronts.
Some progressives see the move as a betrayal of values, while more conservative voices see it as too little, too late evidence that brands shouldn’t have ventured into identity politics in the first place. The result? Brand fatigue. Confusion. A shrinking middle ground.
According to Morning Consult‘s 2025 Brand Trust Tracker, 63% of consumers say a company’s social stance influences their purchase decisions. Of that group, nearly half claim they would actively stop supporting a brand if they believe it’s being disingenuous or inconsistent.
Key Insight: DEI isn’t just about HR policies or seasonal campaigns it’s woven into brand identity. Consumers don’t want performative virtue signaling or reactive backtracking. They want consistency.
What This Means for Brands:
- Clarity trumps compromise. Trying to walk the tightrope can result in alienating both sides.
- DEI is not a marketing tactic, it’s a foundational brand value for many consumers.
- Today’s buyer is more value-driven than ever and has more choices than ever.
For retailers like Target, this raises a critical question: When you stand for everything, do you risk standing for nothing?
Value-Based Retail: Who’s Winning in the Wallet Wars?
As economic uncertainty looms large, many consumers are cutting back on discretionary spending. Inflation and potential tariff hikes are forcing a growing number of households to rethink how and where they spend their money.
According to Yale’s Budget Lab, proposed 2025 tariffs could result in a 2.9% increase in average consumer prices. That means essentials are getting more expensive, and shoppers are becoming even more selective.
In this high stakes environment, retailers that focus on affordability, operational efficiency, and perceived value are thriving. Discount stores, off price retailers, and private label focused chains are outperforming many of their full price counterparts.
Brands on the Rise:
- @Dollar General is doubling down on rural markets and essential goods.
- @Costco Wholesale continues to see membership growth and basket expansion.
- ALDI USA Trader Joe’s and Lidl US are attracting younger, urban consumers through aggressive pricing and modern store formats.
- DTC brands like @Thrive Market and Italic are carving out niches by skipping the middleman and passing savings to consumers.
Takeaway: Consumers are trading down, not necessarily trading out. Brands that deliver high perceived value through price, quality, or experience are positioned to win in this economic cycle.
AI in Marketing: The Gap Between Hype and Implementation
Artificial intelligence has officially crossed over from buzzword to business imperative but execution is proving harder than expected.
According to the IAB’s 2025 “State of Data” report:
- 76% of publishers have begun integrating AI into content and ad operations.
- Only 42% of brands and 37% of agencies say they’ve meaningfully operationalized AI.
- 65% cite data governance and performance metrics as major blockers.
AI offers significant promise from predictive personalization and creative optimization to programmatic ad buying and customer service automation. But many organizations are still struggling with integration due to fragmented data stacks, internal knowledge gaps, and concerns about privacy and compliance.
Where AI Is Gaining Traction:
- Personalization: Dynamic content and tailored user journeys based on behavior and context.
- Media Planning: Smarter budget allocation through AI-powered modeling.
- Creative Testing: Generative AI tools accelerating content production and A/B testing.
- Voice & Visual Search: Retailers exploring AI-enhanced discovery tools beyond the search bar.
The Bottom Line: Brands that treat AI as a plug-and-play solution are falling behind. It’s not just about adoption, it’s about transformation.
In the Spotlight: Industry Headlines Shaping Retail & Media
@Costco Wholesale s Consistency Pays Off
In the face of retail volatility, Costco Wholesale continues to post steady foot traffic and strong financials. Analysts attribute its resilience to value driven pricing, trusted private label brands, and member loyalty. In a shaky economy, reliability becomes a competitive advantage.
Pacsun’s Pop-Up at Coachella
PACSUN is betting on experience as a differentiator. Their “Roadside Stand” at Coachella merges fashion, lifestyle, and culture featuring limited edition drops, influencer activations, and AR filters. It’s a masterclass in how to make pop ups feel authentic, not gimmicky.
Panic Purchasing Returns
With talk of upcoming tariffs, U.S. consumers are accelerating purchases of big ticket items. From iPhones to baby gear, the fear of price hikes is driving early demand, a dynamic that could skew sales cycles and inventory planning for Q2 and Q3.
Sephora Teams Up with WNBA Valkyries
In a move that underscores the evolving landscape of sports and lifestyle partnerships, SEPHORA becomes the official beauty partner of the WNBA’s newest expansion team, the Valkyries. The collaboration highlights the growing intersection between self expression, sports, and inclusivity.
📺 Power Up Your Reach with Flex Ads
Want to meet your audience where they’re already watching? Our Flex Ads deliver CTV style experiences seamlessly placed between content, not interrupting it.
1) Non intrusive, High impact, Brand safe.
2) Capture attention without killing the vibe.
3) Perfect for awareness, engagement, and storytelling.
Join the future of ad placements premium feel, premium results.
Captions are auto generatedPlay
👉 Access Flex Ads Templates Now
What’s Next: Navigating Culture, Commerce, and Consumer Expectations
The retail landscape is entering a new era where consumer loyalty is fickle, values matter more than slogans, and experience often trumps price. Retailers like Target are learning that wavering on core commitments can lead to tangible consequences. Meanwhile, value based competitors and forward thinking marketers are finding new ways to meet consumer needs with clarity and creativity.
As we look ahead:
- Brands must define what they stand for and stick to it.
- Value will increasingly be measured in emotional currency, not just price tags.
- Tech-powered agility, from AI to immersive experiences, will separate the winners from the rest.
Tariff Turmoil: Retailers Scramble to Reframe Value
Recent tariff announcements and their partial delay have retailers pivoting fast. From flash “tariff sales” to controversial surcharges, brands are experimenting with transparency and urgency to drive engagement.
Key takeaways
- Some brands rolled out “Trump Tariff Surcharges,” sparking debate and media buzz.
- DTC and big-box players alike are clearing shelves early to mitigate supply chain risks.
Secondhand Surge: Why Resale is Retail’s Next Big Play
The resale revolution is real and it’s gaining momentum fast. According to thredUP’s latest forecast, the US online secondhand market is expected to reach a staggering $40 billion by 2029, growing at a compound annual rate of 13%.
In 2025 alone, an estimated 42.4 million Americans will shop fashion through resale platforms like Poshmark , Depop, and thredUP representing nearly 1 in 5 digital buyers. Even more eye-opening: the average resale shopper is projected to spend $345.92 this year.
Why it matters for marketers and retailers:
📅 EMARKETER Summit 2025
Commerce Media is evolving fast and if you want to stay ahead, this one’s for you.
On Friday, May 9, EMARKETER is hosting a free virtual summit spotlighting the biggest trends shaping commerce media in 2025. From smarter media network strategies to new ways of measuring performance, this event is built for forward thinking marketers.
Join speakers and brand leaders from PepsiCo, Maev, Kettle & Fire, plus top industry analysts like Sarah Marzano and Max Willens. Expect real insights, not fluff all designed to help you navigate the next wave of media innovation.
🔍 What’s in it for you?
- Actionable trends and takeaways for commerce media
- Expert analysis from top-performing brands
- Free access from anywhere
📢 Don’t miss it. Mark your calendar and register today.
🎥 Streaming Meets Storytelling: Flex Ads and the Pop-Up Economy
With Pacsun launching immersive Coachella activations and HBO’s The Last of Us anchoring massive brand collabs, storytelling is the new conversion funnel.
Examples:
- Mushroom-themed tie-ins for The Last of Us push brands into narrative terrain.
- Nike Kool-Aid sneakers show how TikTok trends translate into tactile campaigns.
ADWEEK Launches adspeak: A Podcast Taking You Inside Our Biggest Stories
ADWEEK has exciting news to share: We’re launching a new weekly podcast called Adspeak, taking you behind the scenes of our reporting.
Look out for the first episode on April 15, in which Ryan and senior reporter Kendra Barnett share how she broke into the chaos of beleaguered indie agency Madwell. And on April 16, we’ll feature an exclusive one on one interview between Madwell CEO Christopher Sojka and Ryan. Listen wherever you get your podcasts; you can’t miss it.
💡 Want help building a brand that’s bold, resilient, and trusted? Let’s chat. 👉 Schedule Call:
Stay ahead. Stay relevant. Stay human. — The Hawk Digital Team
